Hall Effect or Reluctor?

Hall Effect or Reluctor?

The two most important sensors on your engine are the crank and cam sensors, so it’s super important to ensure they’re installed, wired and configured correctly.


Sensor Type: Hall Effect or Reluctor?

Hall effect sensor typically has 3 wires. Power, Signal Ground and the Signal Output.
HALTECH Hall Effect Sensor

A Hall effect sensor produces a consistent digital square wave signal each time a magnet or ferrous metal passes the tip of the sensor, regardless of the speed at which the trigger material.
This makes configuring the ECU to trigger off a Hall effect sensor very simple as you expect the same signal each time a tooth passes the sensor.

When choosing a Hall effect sensor make sure it is compatible with:
• the trigger tooth target material
• tooth width
• tooth gap
• tooth height
Your sensor should also be capable of handling the tooth frequency (the number of teeth it can count in a certain amount of time).

We usually recommend fitting a sensor without any inbuilt filtering as these may cause havoc when you’re trying to detect a missing tooth on a crank trigger wheel.

Hall effect sensors typically like an air-gap (the distance between the sensor and the target material) of around 1mm or 40 thou. Check the sensor’s spec sheet to confirm.

Hall effect sensors tend to dislike high temperatures, so again check the spec sheet. Generally you shouldn’t expect Hall effect sensors to work much above 90 degrees Celsius unless otherwise stated.


Reluctor sensor is typically a 2 wire sensor and does not have any fancy electronics.

A Reluctor is made up of a permanent magnet, a ferromagnetic pole piece and coil of wire. Each end of the coil of
the wire is referred to as the Reluctor +ve and Reluctor -ve which are the signals that are fed into the ECU.

Because of the lack of electronics inside the Reluctor sensors can typically handle temperatures much higher than the Hall effect sensor. It’s not unusual to see them working in environments over 200 degrees Celsius.

The Reluctor sensors are much more sensitive to the Air Gap between the sensor and the trigger material. Getting that gap right is critical, it must be exactly the same between teeth and it is a much tighter gap than in Hall effect sensors, down around 10 thou or 0.25mm or even less in some cases.

This places additional demands on the trigger sensor mount as the margin for error is much less than with a Hall sensor.

Instead of producing an easy to interpret digital square wave like a Hall effect sensor, the Reluctor sensors output magnitude is proportional to the trigger target speed. Basically, the faster the trigger tooth comes past, the higher the signal voltage the Reluctor sensor will generate.

This presents a problem in that the noise the sensor generates also becomes higher, and the exact triggering edge that the ECU calculates the ignition timing off is also more complicated to interpret.

Trigger Input Wiring

For a Hall effect sensor use:
5V, 8V or 12V supply to the sensor (depending on its requirements)
0V Signal Ground and Trigger + which is connected to the signal wire from the sensor.
For a Reluctor sensor use:
Trigger+ to the positive side of the reluctor sensor
Trigger – to the negative side of the reluctor sensor.
Pay special attention to this wiring, as mixing and matching sensor wiring will cause all sorts of nightmares.

Conclusion

Hall effect sensors are easy to mount and easy to configure in the ECU software, however they don’t like getting hot and depending on the model may “filter” or miss teeth that you really want to detect.
Reluctor sensors don’t mind the heat and are extremely reliable, however they require time in setting up the trigger voltages vs. engine RPM and require a very accurate sensor mount in order to provide a very small gap between the sensor and trigger tooth to ensure trouble free operation.

Want to know more?









    • Related Articles

    • Nissan CAS – Facts and Fiction

      The Hot Debate One of the most hotly debated topics within the global RB community is the accuracy of the Nissan OEM Cam Angle Sensor (CAS). In this article we will attempt to separate facts from fallacies, explain the cause of the problem and ...
    • Reluctor Sensor Types

      Variable Reluctance Transducers (VRT or simply reluctor) – this kind of sensor produces a sine wave output. Generally a VRT sensor will have only 2 wires (a third wire may be present but its generally a shield wire to help protect the signal from ...
    • Engine Trigger Systems Explained

      The most important sensors on your engine are the Crankshaft and Camshaft Position Sensors. These sensors have to be wired and configured correctly in order for the engine to start, let alone run well.         We refer to the crankshaft position ...
    • Digital Hall Effect and Optical Sensor Types

      The second type of sensor found of crank and camshafts known as a Hall Effect (this includes optical sensors) sensor. This style of sensor has a transistor and some electronics built into the sensor itself and will generally require a power supply ...
    • Trigger System Configuration

      Engine Configuration - Trigger System Page This section contains setup information for configuring your engines' trigger system, including crank and cam trigger patterns and sensors. Trigger Configuration Trigger Type This is set to the type of ...